On Monday, Bloomreach announced it had acquired AthenaHQ, a Y Combinator-backed startup that tracks how brands show up in AI-generated answers and helps them show up more often. CMSWire's write-up on Tuesday framed the deal around Bloomreach's goal to tie AI visibility to revenue, and the news was posted to X a little after 11 a.m. Pacific.
About 25 minutes later, another post summarized new data from SparkToro's Rand Fishkin and argued that founders shouldn't move their whole SEO budget toward optimizing for AI answers, since ChatGPT hasn't replaced Google.
Read side by side, they capture the budget question CMOs are being pushed to answer: AI visibility now has an acquisition price, so what is it actually returning?
What Bloomreach is getting
AthenaHQ was founded by Andrew Yan and Alan Yao, who came from Google and ServiceNow respectively. Its main product, the Athena Citation Engine, is a machine-learning model that scores a brand's content and estimates how likely AI engines are to cite it. The platform also produces content aimed at AI search demand and optimizes product pages for assistant recommendations, with integrations into Shopify, GA4, ChatGPT and Claude, according to CMSWire. Terms weren't disclosed.
Bloomreach's Loomi AI engine already handles personalization for more than 1,400 brands, so the logic of the deal is straightforward. AthenaHQ works on the point where a shopper, or an AI agent acting for one, first comes across a brand, and Bloomreach handles what happens after that. The company's announcement leans on the agentic angle, warning that an agent that can't find a brand won't recommend it.
Adobe got into this category earlier with its own LLM Optimizer, and it now owns Semrush as well. For most large marketing teams, AI visibility tools will probably arrive as an add-on to software they already license.
What independent studies show
Most of the optimistic numbers come from vendors. CMSWire cites Conductor research covering more than 13,000 enterprise domains, which found AI-referred sessions up 527% year over year and converting at 4.4 times the rate of organic search. Those growth rates start from a very low baseline.
In October, Fishkin gathered three independent studies in a post that asked whether AI visibility is a marketing boondoggle. Marie Haynes looked at 100 websites over 12 months and found that ChatGPT accounted for 0.62% of their traffic, with all LLMs together at 0.73%, below DuckDuckGo. Google drove 97% of their conversions.
SEOWorks UK found organic search sending roughly 39 times as much traffic as AI assistants, and AI visitors converted worse than organic visitors on 23 of the 63 sites it compared. Kevin Indig tested whether AI exposure leads to more branded searches and direct visits, an effect AEO vendors often cite, and found no reliable link in his sample.
Broader search data points the same way. SparkToro and Datos found Google handling 73.7% of desktop searches across 41 high-search websites, compared with 3.2% for AI tools. Similarweb reported that 95% of ChatGPT users also used Google during the same three-month period, which suggests most people are adding ChatGPT to their routine rather than switching.
Measurement is its own problem. Earlier SparkToro research showed that AI tools are highly inconsistent when asked for brand recommendations, returning different lists when the same prompt is repeated. A product built to forecast citations has to account for that variance somehow.
The case for a bigger number
OpenAI's own figures look very different. This month, consumer-product lead Adam Fry told Big Technology's Alex Kantrowitz that ChatGPT's search-like query volume is now roughly one-fifth of Google's, while SparkToro's earlier estimates put the ratio closer to 200 to 1.
The two figures measure different behavior. OpenAI counts every question that triggers a web lookup, while traffic studies count visits that actually reach a website. On that second measure, Ahrefs had ChatGPT at 0.36% of tracked website visits in October, compared with 24.74% for Google. Lots of people are asking ChatGPT questions, and only a small share of those answers send anyone to a brand's site.
AI answers could carry real influence over buying decisions while barely registering as a traffic source.
Treating AI answers as brand media
Fishkin suggests thinking of AI answers as a brand channel, "a digital billboard if you will," and budgeting and measuring them on those terms. If AI mainly affects which brands make a buyer's shortlist, traffic reports will understate it and revenue attribution will be hard to pin down.
Bloomreach says AthenaHQ will close that attribution gap. One ecommerce analysis of the deal notes that revenue from shoppers who click through from an AI assistant can be measured today, but neither company has published evidence buyers can check showing that a specific AEO recommendation led to a sale.
Much of the AI answer exposure brands get also happens on Google. SparkToro found that 68% of U.S. Google searches in early 2026 ended without a click to any website, and AI Overviews appeared on more than a fifth of searches. For many brands, improving AI visibility and improving Google visibility will be largely the same work.
Our take
Bloomreach made a smart move here. Most AI visibility tools stop at a dashboard that tells a brand how often it gets mentioned. By folding AthenaHQ into a platform that already runs search, personalization and marketing for more than 1,400 brands, Bloomreach is trying to follow that first AI-driven discovery all the way through to a purchase. If it can show that connection with real customer data, it will have answered the question most of the category has been avoiding.
The timing works in its favor too. The independent studies show AI traffic is still small, which means brands that build the habit and the measurement now will have a head start when it grows. And because AthenaHQ's model is built around predicting which content AI engines will cite, it pushes brands toward work that pays off on every channel: building a reputation that credible sources write about, and publishing content with enough expertise behind it to be worth citing.
We'd still keep SEO budgets where they are, since Google produces most of the clicks and conversions today and good search content feeds AI answers as well. Alongside that, a dedicated line for AI visibility makes sense, judged on share of voice and consideration over several quarters. Ask any vendor, Bloomreach included, how it handles variation in AI answers, and start segmenting AI referral traffic in your own analytics so you can check the results yourself.
Bloomreach is betting early on where brand discovery is heading, and the deal gives its customers a practical way to start preparing for that shift now.




