Google and Reddit gave publishers two very different accounts of the same search page this fall. On October 15, Google announced a wider rollout of news carousels in AI Search. By the end of the month, Reddit CEO Steve Huffman was telling investors that AI Mode sent his company almost no traffic. A publisher can have a better seat on Google’s page and still have fewer people turn up at its own.
Google’s change is worth having. Readers in more places and languages can see timely articles together, including coverage from publishers they’ve marked as preferred sources. Google also said it would put inline links higher in some answers. The announcement described where a reader could click. It gave a CMO considering a newsroom budget very little to go on about why that reader would.
Reddit Had Plenty of Visibility
When we covered Reddit’s plan to test a login requirement, the striking detail was how well Reddit had done by the usual measure of AI visibility. Its threads had become a staple of answers across search services. Yet Reddit reported that its Google search referrals had fallen by more than a million a week on average in October. It planned to test requiring a login in selected markets outside the US. Those figures covered Google referrals broadly. They don’t tell us what the new carousel did. They do explain why a publisher might read Google’s announcement with less enthusiasm than the marketing team buying citation-tracking software.
We’d be wary of a proposal to produce more news briefs on the strength of this rollout. Google can give a reader the date, the price and the terms of a product launch in the space above the first link. Paying an editor to rearrange those same facts is an expensive way to find out how little a click is worth to someone who already has the answer.
The Part Worth Opening
Earlier this month a widely shared post argued that several AI search startups were struggling. It cited Ramp spending data. We checked the claim against the figures Ramp actually collects. Ramp can see card and bill payments by its customers. That makes its figures useful for comparing vendors inside that group. It also means a change in one vendor’s share tells you less about the health of its entire business than the post suggested. A CMO halfway through evaluating one of those vendors has a reason to open that story. The distinction could change a purchase.
There’s another example closer to home. Before OpenAI announced its business profiles, our sister newsroom State of AI covered screenshots of a claim-your-business prompt. Once the product launched, our State of Brand story examined what marketers could actually see: mentions, profile views and clicks. The buyer’s original prompt was still out of view. Outlever publishes both titles. A marketing chief who’d already read the launch news could still use the second piece to decide what to ask of the new dashboard.
That’s where we’d put the next editorial dollar. Give the reporter time to open the dataset, read the footnote or try the dashboard. By all means take the spot in Google’s carousel. Budget for the work a buyer might remember well enough to come looking for the publication by name.
FAQ
What changed in Google AI Search on October 15? Google announced that its carousels for timely coverage would reach more locations and languages. It also described a separate test highlighting official sources for questions with only one or two authoritative destinations.
Will appearing in a news carousel bring readers to our site? The placement gives people a route to the article. To judge what it delivers, look at the search referrals you can identify and what those readers do afterward. Keep visits you can’t trace out of any carousel-specific count.
Which stories should a brand newsroom fund? Start with a disputed claim that matters to a buyer and a source who can settle it. A reporter who can explain what a vendor comparison measures has a better assignment than one asked to summarize the rankings.
Publisher disclosure: Outlever builds and operates newsrooms for brands. It also publishes thestateofbrand.com and thestateofai.com as its own editorial properties.




